Michelin Must Face Lawsuit on Fatal Crash Involving Used Tire, Texas Court Rules

Michelin Must Face Lawsuit on Fatal Crash Involving Used Tire, Texas Court Rules

A Texas appellate court rejected Michelin North America Inc.’s bid to escape a lawsuit involving a 2015 fatal accident allegedly caused by a defect in one of its tires.

A Texas appellate court rejected Michelin North America Inc.’s bid to escape a lawsuit involving a 2015 fatal accident allegedly caused by a defect in one of its tires.

Michelin says that the tire involved in the case – a Uniroyal Tiger Paw Freedom – was sold as a used tire from a “third party wholly unrelated to MNA (Michelin North America).”

The lawsuit, filed by Texas resident Brenda Isela Lopez de Santiago, states that while Lopez was in the passenger seat of her 2002 Honda CR-V SUV, the right back tire on the car failed, causing a rollover accident. Lopez, who was not driving the car at the time, was injured in the crash, and her daughter, who was in the back seat, died.

Lopez claims that the car came with Uniroyal tires already installed, and they had already been used at the time of purchase. She alleged both in her pleadings and
in an affidavit that the tire was previously purchased in Texas and that no one at the car dealership ever replaced the tires.

MORE COVERAGE: Check out the latest issue of Tire Review 

Michelin argued that because an intervening retail customer removed the tire from the stream of commerce and then sold the tire again in a secondary market before it ended up on Lopez’s car, that itself and its distributor are not liable for the accident under the lawsuit.

The Texas Eighth Court of Appeals said this week it was unconvinced by Michelin’s argument, saying in an opinion “Michelin failed to refute the plaintiff’s claim that the original tire sale took place in Texas, and the secondary sale here arose from and related to that Texas-based initial sale.”

A Michelin North America spokesman said the company is evaluating its options based on the court’s decision, and the company “remains confident in its position on this matter based on our belief that certain aspects of the law remain unclear.”

You May Also Like

Firestone Airide Tennessee Plant Recognized for Safety

This is the facility’s fourth STAR award, reflecting the company’s and
teammates’ commitment to a safe and healthy work environment.

Firestone Airide, a division of Firestone Industrial Products Company, announced that the company’s Dyersburg, Tenn., manufacturing facility has received its fourth Volunteer STAR (Safety Through Accountability and Recognition) award.

The Volunteer STAR award recognizes the best-of-the-best in safety and health programming and performance. Patterned after the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration Voluntary Protection Program, the Volunteer STAR award is the state’s highest honor for workplace safety and health.

Eight Great Practices for Creating a Winning Team Culture

In your quest to be the absolute best tire/auto service business you can possibly be, you can have a beautiful facility, state-of-the-art equipment and all the amenities to enrich your customer’s experience, but if don’t have a great, “Winning Team” culture, then you still don’t have a truly great company. Related Articles – What Your

What Your Credit Score Can do to Your Business

If you want to explain your business in the future, one thing you need to prioritize is your credit score. Having bad business credit can negatively impact your shop in many ways – from causing difficulties securing financing to getting approved for a lease. Related Articles – Rising Gas Prices Make Tire Distributors Rethink Pricing,

Credit Score Business
Ferrante: What I’ve Learned From Listening to 100,000 Sales Calls

Back in 2014, I authored an article titled, “Are Your Tire/Auto Service Salespeople ‘Winging It’ on the Phone?” At the time the article was published, my Pinnacle Performance Training team and I had evaluated approximately 25,000 sales calls between tire/auto service sales staff and prospective customers. In May of this year, we reached a milestone

What Do Your Signs Say About Your Shop?

Signs are everywhere. Some communicate their message effectively, while others fall flat – and some are just downright confusing. Related Articles – Creating a Positive Work Environment – Using Data to Enrich the Customer Experience – Microlearning Makes the Tire Industry Smarter, More Profitable The Five Man Electrical Band sang in 1971: “Sign, sign, everywhere


Other Posts

Apollo Tyres Opens Digital Innovation Center in India

In partnership with the Telangana Government, Apollo Tyres announced the launch of a digital innovation centre in Hyderabad, India.

MEMA Announces New Structure and Brand

The realignment will allow the association to better serve members and prepare for the future of mobility.

RNR Tire Express Named to Entrepreneur’s Franchise 500 List

The RNR team is celebrating 10-plus years being named to the Franchise 500 list.

‘New Culture,’ Dealer Commitment to Fuel Nexen Tire’s Growth

Hear what Nexen Tire executives have to say about the tire industry, supply chain and what dealers can expect from the company this year.