Federal Court Upholds Sanction in Goodyear Case - Tire Review Magazine

Federal Court Upholds Sanction in Goodyear Case

Goodyear_NEW_HQ_Exterior_02RSA federal court of appeals for the 9th circuit has upheld a 2012 order imposing $2.7 million in sanctions against Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. and two of its lawyers. The court also upheld non-monetary sanctions against the tiremaker.

In a 2-1 ruling the court found that the sanctions given to Goodyear and its two lawyers were lawful and appropriate given the district courts conclusion that the parties participated in a “years-long course of misconduct,” in the initial lawsuit. Monetary sanctions were awarded to plaintiffs in the first case. Non-monetary sanctions imposed require Goodyear to disclose in all future lawsuits related to the G159 tire its deceit in the case.

A spokesman for Goodyear told Tire Review, “We are disappointed with the decision and are considering our options.”

The initial case, Haeger v. The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., involved a Tucson, Ariz., couple who were injured when the Goodyear G159 front tire on their motor home failed at highway speeds causing the vehicle to overturn.  In their case, filed in 2005, the couple claimed that the G159 tire could fail after prolonged heat even when properly inflated and could prematurely fail due to such heat degradation when used on motor homes. An attorney for the couple demanded Goodyear provide all information it had on testing the G159 model of tire.

According to court documents, Goodyear had performed testing on the G159 tire prior to sale, but when asked for its test results on the G159 tires, Goodyear and its attorneys “failed to search for, and/or withheld the relevant and responsive G159 testing documents.”

The couple eventually settled outside of court with Goodyear in 2010. Later it was discovered that Goodyear in fact had internal heat and speed tests on the G159 tire, and the tiremaker “had withheld evidence it was required to produce during discovery,” according to court documents.

The couple later filed for sanctions against Goodyear in 2011. The court imposed sanctions against Goodyear and its lawyer’s that lead to the recent appeal in the federal district court.

You May Also Like

Falken Tires Earns RTS Top Market Share Increase Award

The award acknowledges Falken’s commitment to innovation and quality in the passenger car/light truck segment.


Falken Tires, a subsidiary of Sumitomo Rubber Industries, received the RTS Top Market Share Increase award in the passenger car/light truck tires segment. The company said the RTS Top Market Share Increase award is a testament to its commitment to innovation, quality and customer satisfaction.

"We are thrilled and humbled to receive this esteemed award," Rob Montasser, vice president of sales said. "It’s a testament to the hard work and dedication of the entire SRNA team. Additionally, we would like to express our gratitude to our dealer partners across North America for trusting the Falken brand, and for their support in our growth within their businesses.”

Autel Energy Showcases EV Charging Solutions, Electrified Bronco at CES

At CES, Autel Energy showcased its suite of EV charging solutions and an electrified 1969 Ford Bronco.

2019 Newsmakers: Bridgestone Americas

Nearly all products in the Firestone family of tires have been upgraded over the past three years, and Bridgestone is on track to have all of its consumer tire portfolio across both the Bridgestone and Firestone brands either upgraded or replaced by the end of 2020.

2019 Newsmakers: Nokian Tyres

Nokian Tyres opened its first U.S. manufacturing facility and launched numerous new products. See what’s in store for 2020.

2019 Newsmakers: Nexen Tire America

Nexen Tire opened its North American Technology Center and debuted the Roadian GTX. Find out what’s in store for 2020.


Other Posts

Discount Tire Awards Scholarship to USF Pro Championships Driver

Discount Tire awarded $664,500 in scholarship money to USF Pro 2000 champion Myles Rowe.

Bridgestone Raises Over $2.44 Million for United Way

Bridgestone’s annual efforts, including a record-breaking golf tournament, raised funds supporting Middle Tennessee communities.

Hofmann Debuts Advanced Armored Series 2400P Wheel Balancer

Hofmann said its Hofmann balancer ensures precise balancing, smartSonar technology and versatile use for standard and EV wheels.

Toyo Tires Promotes New VP of Sales

Mike Snyder has been promoted to vice president of sales. Snyder previously served as the sr. director of sales, strategic accounts.