There For The Taking - Tire Review Magazine

There For The Taking

Service and maintenance opportunities grow, but multiple challenges and competition can trip up tire dealers

Ever since service stations moved away from vehicle service and repair and converted their businesses to convenience stores, independent tire dealers have captured a greater share of the auto care industry’s maintenance and repair market.

Today’s 25,000-plus independent tire dealerships, em­ploying 178,000 people, continue (for the sixth consecutive year) to dominate the $36 billion domestic passenger tire retail market with more than 60% of sales.

Looking back not that long ago was the 2008-09 reces­sion, which had a dramatic impact on the U.S. consumer tire retail market. However, these two years were followed by two robust sales years of $31.2 billion in 2010 and $37.3 billion in 2011, registering year-over-year increases of 20.9% and 19.6%, respectively. After a slight sales dip in 2012, the demand for tires in 2013 increased nearly 4%.

Looking forward, the general overall auto service, parts and repair sales for tire dealers for this year is projected to reach $17.2 billion, with an annual increase of 3.7% through 2017.

Along with this increase in busi­ness comes numerous opportunities and challenges familiar to the independent service and repair shops. Finding trained and qualified technicians, margin pressure, e-tailing, telematics, legislative and regulatory issues and competition from new car dealers are among the top issues that might keep independent tire dealers up at night. I will focus on the last three.

Telematics: The Connected Car

Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge

Few topics draw more attention from auto care pro­fes­sionals than vehicle telematics and the impact of embedded communication systems on the future of the industry. Vehicle manufacturers are appealing to the desire for connectivity and conven­ience by introducing technology that beams content into the vehicle, such as traffic, entertainment and parking information.

But that same technology is used to extract information from the vehicle – location, speed, air bag status and diagnostic data – which is stored and/or shared back to the automaker.

The network is naturally closed and supposedly secure, and favors communication with the OEM and its dealer network. This amounts to the vehicle manufacturers being “online” with their product while the independent auto care industry re­mains out of that loop – “offline,” if you will. With the em­bed­- ded technology, the playing field for service and maintenance opportunities is no longer level.

In the short term, technology innovators have developed a variety of connectivity solutions that either plug into the OBDII port or make use of smartphone technology – or both. This interface with the vehicle enables remote diagnostics and other vehicle management services. The cost of this tech­nology is coming down and cellular data plans for vehicles are quite affordable. But our industry is still sorting out the business model because, regardless of the cost, charging the consumer anything to receive diagnostics and maintenance reminders is a tough sell.

Our best hope for the long-term future of connectivity is in a standards-setting initiative called the Vehicle Station Gateway (VSG). The VSG is essentially a standardized layer of software that would manage communication between any authorized party and the on-vehicle network. The current VSG proposal includes provisions for security, authentication, communication traffic management and data standardization.

Most importantly, the VSG proposal calls for non-discriminatory access to the vehicle network. That will assure that independent service providers – like tire dealers – will have fair and equal access to telematic networks.

The vehicles of tomorrow will be the subject of connectivity with multiple roadside audiences. Of course the auto care industry is interested in vehicle operations data and diag­nostics; the “intelligent transportation system” is interested in location, speed and other safety parameters; insurance companies are interested in acc­e­l­eration, braking and hours of operation; California will be interested in compl­iance with emission regulations; and the list goes on. Tiremakers may even want to leverage the technology to capture performance data for R&D purposes, or to address quality concerns, or com­plete the loop from factory to fitment.

The case for a single, standardized Vehicle Station Gateway is driven by a lower cost and ease of deployment versus multiple network interfaces. On-board safety and security is actually enhanced by focusing all efforts on a single solution. And, as a public policy matter, it will become impossible for the vehicle manufacturers to discriminate over who can access the vehicle network. Ultimately, telematics will become a “Consumers’ Right to Choose” issue.

Competing With Car Dealers

Servicing the vehicle fleet of the future will pit the independent repair shops and tire dealers against new car dealers that will promote having all of the latest diagnostic and repair technology from the car companies to work on their highly sophisticated, computer-driven vehicles. So far independent shops and tire dealers have been able to hold their ground based on better service, convenience and prices, but the future will not allow them to rest on their laurels.

Technicians working in independent shops will need access to the most up-to-date tools, software and repair information in order to compete with dealerships to provide any type of service beyond simple maintenance. The cost to obtain these resources and to keep them updated, already very high, likely will only grow.

In 2013, the Auto Care Association and the Coalition for Auto Repair Equality signed the Right to Repair Memorandum of Understanding that requires car companies to make available to independent shops – at a fair and reasonable cost – the same information, tools and software available to their franchised dealerships.

Of major importance, the MOU requires that car companies, beginning in model year 2018, house all of their diagnostic and repair software in a cloud where it would be accessible to independent shops by subscription on a daily, monthly and yearly basis.

Under this scenario, a technician working at an independent shop will have the ability to download all of the software for a particular vehicle to a generic PC and then connect to the vehicle using an interface meeting either a SAE 2534 or ISO 22900 standard.

Once fully implemented, this requirement has the potential to reduce tooling and software costs for shops, while providing them with greater capability to cost effectively service a wider variety of vehicles.

In addition to the information and tool challenges, shops will need to ensure that their technicians are prop­erly trained to work on today’s highly sophisticated systems. A commitment to training for indep­endent tire dealers will be crucial for them to compete with car dealers that have direct access to car company-developed training.

Car companies will pose additional challenges to independents by pushing the perception with consumers that only their parts and dealer service facilities should be used to maintain and repair their high-tech vehicle. But it is one thing to say that they can better service the vehicle, it is quite another when they are telling consumers that using anything but the dealer or genuine OE parts might void their new vehicle warranty.

Legislative, Regulatory Protection

Kia OEM oil filters are produced by Mahle, which also sells its own line to the replacement market.
Kia OEM oil filters are produced by Mahle, which also sells its own line to the replacement market.

Enacted in 1975, the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act (MMWA) makes it illegal for a company to condition a warranty on the use of a non-original part or service. Yet, the Auto Care Association has seen a growing number of examples where car companies have either inferred or explicitly stated that using a non-OE part would void their new car warranty.

Recently, Kia issued a technical service bulletin to its dealers saying that consumers will not be eligible for warranty coverage if a non-Kia oil filter was used.

Fortunately, Consumer Reports picked up on the Kia TSB, but unfor­tunately it advised its readers to only bring their Kia back to the dealer. The Auto Care Association has filed a complaint with the FTC regarding the Kia oil filter TSB as well as other car company actions and scare tactics that appear to violate the MMWA.

Thus far, the FTC has yet to respond to these complaints.

Making matters worse, car dealer­ships also are playing the game, putting consumers in the middle by saying that they will not cover a warranty failure because maintenance was performed at independent shops. Often independent tire dealers, who have done nothing wrong, must cover the repair or risk losing the customer forever.

It is critical that tire dealers and repair shops provide their customers with information regarding their MMWA-protected rights under new car warranties. A good resource for this is a consumer alert published by the FTC which can be found at:­articles/0138-auto-warranties-routine-maintenance

The Tire Aging Issue

Another issue that faces tire dealers is the question of tire age. In fact, the tire age controversy is shared across the auto care industry as certain safety advocates continue to press for time limits on tire service life.

The lack of agreement among the various tire and vehicle manufacturers only creates more confusion; some say tires should be taken out of service at six years from the date of manufacture, while other say 10 years is correct, and still others claim a tire’s age is irrelevant.

While tire age questions continue to generate publicity, this association believes that retailers have to follow their tire manufacturers’ recommendations. We were also glad to see that NHTSA, with some degree of finality, issued its tire aging report in March, stating that, “At this time, the agency does not believe it is necessary for motor vehicle safety to add a tire aging requirement to its light vehicle tire standard…”.

Still, many suspect that this matter is far from resolved, so tire dealers and the industry will have to redouble their efforts to educate customers and help them through often-confusing opinions and information.

I believe the future looks pretty darn good for independent tire dealers. Why?

  • Average annual miles driven is on the rise
  • Consumers are still holding onto their vehicles longer
  • Roller coaster gasoline prices are smooth­ing out
  • New agreements guarantee access to diagnostic tools and information for independents
  • Projected steady growth into 2017 for vehicle service and parts sales

There certainly are some great opp­ortunities in the vehicle service market for tire dealers. But taking advantage of those opportunities will require greater commitment and effort to meet the challenges of vehicle technology, competition and consumer demand.

You May Also Like

The Benefits of Continuous Learning in the Tire Industry

The first step in any successful training program is to identify what’s important for your staff to learn.


As you have likely experienced firsthand, the past few years have seen rapid changes in the tire industry. Supply chain delays, labor constraints and the shift to electrification—among countless other macro challenges—are constantly requiring dealers to reevaluate their business strategies and operations to adjust to the current environment. It’s critical that flexibility and resiliency remain top-of-mind as dealers navigate these obstacles. One way to remain agile is fostering a culture of learning and development for your staff. At ATD, we’ve found that integrating technology, insights and data analytics into our reskilling and training programs is helping to create sustainable solutions. By understanding the importance of training and how to build an effective program, you, too, can take advantage of the many benefits for both you and your business.

Mass. Lawmakers Could End Right to Repair Impasse

A Boston Globe editorial suggests that the state legislature “might be able to break the stalemate.”

Mass-lawmakers right to repair
AI & Your Tire Shop: Using it to Your Advantage

AI could revolutionize the tire industry. It’s time to adapt and invest for success.

AI Stock image
Finding TPMS Sales & Maintenance Opportunities

Follow five steps to keep TPMS systems functioning properly.

Airless Tires Represent Another Milestone Breakthrough

Airless tires, a potential game-changing breakthrough, may become mainstream by 2024.


Other Posts

Six Solutions for Recruiting and Retaining Talent

Tire dealers are actively recruiting and retaining employees through job postings, employee benefits and more.

Top Technology Trends Shaping the Tire Industry

Implementing technologies such as artificial intelligence and digital scanning technology can allow tire dealers to efficiently and accurately gather data to improve a customer’s driving experience.

DOT mobile tire scanner anyline
Adopting a Solutions-First Mindset

The latest digital edition of Tire Review delves into shop solutions for business issues.

Four Keys to Creating a Succession Plan That Works

Do you have a plan in place to ensure your business maintains its success after you leave?