How Independent Tire Dealers Are Standing Up To Their Biggest Competitors

How Independent Tire Dealers Are Standing Up To Their Biggest Competitors

When asked who their toughest competitor is, 30% of independent tire dealers pointed to national tire retail chains.

The tire industry is more competitive than ever, with independent dealers facing challenges from big chains, box stores and online sellers. But who do tire dealers see as their toughest competition, and how is the landscape changing?

When asked who their toughest competitor is, 30% of independent tire dealers pointed to national tire retail chains, followed by other local independent dealers at 21%. Dealers are also feeling competition from big box retailers, with 14% citing them as the top competitor. Online tire retailers and wholesale distributors took 13% and 12% of votes, respectively.

It’s no surprise the big chains are seen as the top threat – with hundreds of locations and deep pockets. But what makes these competitors so tough? The number one factor cited in our data was lower pricing, with 68% of respondents saying as much. Meanwhile, 35% say the fact that big chains have a large number of locations affects competition. Because of their inventory volume and amount of locations, chain retailers often can leverage that to offer reduced prices that independents struggle to match.

Other advantages of the bigger chains and competition, in general, are bigger marketing budgets and convenience factors.

We also asked dealers how competition has changed with the rise of private equity investment in retail chains. Private equity firms consolidate chains under holding companies and provide capital to expand through acquisitions and new store openings. 24% of our respondents said private equity is driving much higher competition, while 29% said it’s moderately increased competition. This data tells us that over half of respondents say private equity investment has intensified competition by enabling retail chains to rapidly expand and modernize stores in ways most independent dealers can’t afford.

Finally, we looked at the impact of competition from big box retailers. 33% of respondents said big box retailers have only moderately increased competition and 33% said competition stayed the same. Meanwhile, 17% of dealers say big box retailers have increased competition substantially. Our data also showed that 50% of independent tire dealers estimate having one to four big box stores within 10 miles of their location. Additionally, 41% of respondents have to contend with five to ten stores in close proximity, meaning tire buyers have more options – potentially limiting revenue for independent retailers.

Due to all the options your customers have, you need to differentiate yourself. While the competitive environment is demanding, fear not independent dealers – you still maintain key advantages like your local expertise and longstanding community ties. However, understanding the competition will allow independents to tailor offerings and demonstrate their unique value to the community.

Take Tire Review’s 2022 Top Shop winner, Telle Tire & Auto Service, for example. What does Telle, an independent tire dealer, attribute its success over competition to? Continuous training and education for techs, a marketing strategy that builds brand consistency for all locations and providing excellent customer service – meaning clean lobbies, loaner cars, and technicians that treat customers like family.

Tire industry competition continues to get fierce…how are you dealing with the competitive pressures in your market?

With over 23 locations across Missouri and Illinois, Telle Tire has made three acquisitions and added five new store locations in 2023 alone.

You May Also Like

Don’t estimate when it comes to parking brake adjustments

Let’s discuss a couple of different components of parking brakes to find out the best practices for adjusting them.


The parking or emergency brake has two crucial functions. First, it must hold the vehicle on an incline and second, stop it within a specific distance if the hydraulic brakes fail. These standards, established by the Department of Transportation, must be met with minimal force. Let’s discuss a couple of different components of parking brakes to find out the best practices for adjusting them.

How do you define a tire tier?

Tire dealers provided various views on what attributes define a tire manufacturer’s tier.

RwtNMAR tire tiers
Don’t overlook the importance of EV service training

We look at our data from tire dealers surrounding EV service and discuss how not providing training could be detrimental.

RwtN Feb
Using regional trends to develop an EV tire and service strategy

Understanding where EV hotspots in the country are can better prepare you and your customers for current EV trends.

What Economic Trends Affected the Tire Industry in 2023?

We’re reviewing data from 2023 that tells us a lot about automotive and tire trends moving forward.


Other Posts

How the Autel MaxiSYS Ultra enhances service efficiency at Mighty Auto Pro

Time is money in vehicle repair, and the Autel MaxiSYS Ultra is all about enhancing technicians’ diagnostic prowess.

Educate your customers utilizing AI

Discover how to generate quick, accurate explanations for repair orders and estimates, boosting your shop’s credibility and customer trust.

Important tips for wheel bearing service

Complaints like exhaust leaks to tire balance issues to vague statements like “it just doesn’t sound right” may mean bad wheel bearings.

Sonic Tools USA offers tools to beat back the technician shortage

Andrew Coccari, VP of Sales and Marketing at Sonic Tools USA, delves into the causes of the technician shortage and offers some novel solutions to address the need for help around the country.

WT YT-Sonic-Tools-1400