Trying to Get to the Bottom of World-Class Customer Service - Tire Review Magazine

Trying to Get to the Bottom of World-Class Customer Service

Thanks to our annual search for the "best of the best" tire dealers through the Top Shop Award program, we often are asked for tips on how to win this honor.

To which we respond: "The best dealerships are those that are very good at everything. More than anything, though, they have an obvious world-class customer-first attitude that permeates the entire organization from top to bottom."

And then we’re asked: “So, just what is ‘world-class customer service?’”

This is where thoughtful silence ensues, emphasized by prayerful glances to the heavens as though the true answer can only come from above. In fact, we’re hoping we can think of an excuse to excuse ourselves before trying to offer an an­swer that is not so clear-cut.

The real truth is that great customer service is totally up to the customer. They are the ones experiencing the “customer service” afforded by your tire dealership. It would be far easier to describe quantum mechanics than to provide a definitive explanation of “world-class customer service.”

We’re not trying to dodge the question, but there is no black-and-white, absolute 100% sure thing, bet-the-house-on-it world-class customer service system.

For every 100 customers, there are 100 entirely different sets of expectations. Some are simple, cut-and-dried transactions: warm smile, personable tone, thorough and easy-to-understand responses, tire recommendations that make sense, well-explained service- and tire-cost estimates, comprehensive review of vehicle systems, comeback-proof repairs, clean vehicle ready to go at the prescribed time, and a few other points.

Unfortunately, others are more difficult, often because the customer’s native mode is “difficult.” Or a human error intervened, accidentally creating a tough customer service pickle that must be carefully and thoughtfully navigated.

Defining “world-class customer service” becomes difficult because what we think should be simple and cut-and-dried is not so. What are “easy-to-understand responses” to some are “gobbledy-gook” to others. “Tire recommendations that make sense” to most can be heard as “trying to rip me off” by certain customers.

Everyone is different, and that’s why a singular, true definition of “world-class customer service” is entirely in the hands of the customer.

Or is it?

Skilled practitioners can suss out most potentially difficult customers early in the sales process, and adjust their approach to match the situation. This includes letting others in the service chain – from the tire tech to the service desk – redouble their efforts to win over Mr. Grumpypants.

They can smell from a parking lot away the potential for an unfortunate customer experience, and adjust their tone and manner to put things on the right path from the start.

They can plan ahead in an effort to deliver world-class customer service to world-class pains in the arse. You can avert customer service disasters by doing the unexpected nice things, like vacuuming out a customer’s car, washing the windows, keeping up with the latest waiting area magazines or offering free coffee or soft drinks, having an area to amuse a flustered mom’s little ones.

These are not bank account breakers, by any means. These are how you build a sustainable customer base, creating additional reasons to pick your shop when it comes time for new rubber or brake pads instead of turning to the price-guy down the street.

We’d all quickly recognize bad customer service because we’ve all lived through it. Many, many, many unfortunate times. Despite years of often ugly experiences, it’s as difficult to clearly define crappy customer service as it is to spell out great service. We know it when we step in it, but don’t ask us to explain it!

I had occasion to step in it recently while trying to help a family member sort through an insurance issue. This was a big, major, national insurance company, not unlike the one I have my personal insurance with. But I had not dealt with this outfit, and now I have no reason to do so in the future.

Over the course of five painful days, I made contact with seven different people in the company’s ill-named “Customer Service Department.” Over that time, it seemed no one communicated with any others, that there was no one file – paper or electronic – that held notes from my previous contact. I envisioned this long hallway of tiny gray offices, with those old-school vacuum tubes clogged with memos and file notes and letters and such, all zipping along to nowhere in particular.

And that’s exactly how I was treated. None of my conversations with the agents were “recorded for training purposes,” so none of the conversations featured an actual resolution of any kind. Or the hope for one. They were happy to offer their “apologies,” but no effort to help me unpeel the onion layers separating the problem from complete resolution.

Not world-class customer service. And for that, they have lost a customer for life.

You May Also Like

A Focus on People Defines Today’s Top Shops

For the past few years in the tire industry, there has been a keen focus on people– keeping people on your staff happy, attracting new ones to your business, finding ways to challenge tenured employees…the list goes on. In fact, tire dealers like you are getting pretty innovative in ways they’re working with their staff


For the past few years in the tire industry, there has been a keen focus on people– keeping people on your staff happy, attracting new ones to your business, finding ways to challenge tenured employees…the list goes on. In fact, tire dealers like you are getting pretty innovative in ways they’re working with their staff to create a great work environment, which in turn, creates success for the business.

Look Inside Lamborghini’s VIP Lounge in NYC and Drive a Urus with Us

During a recent ride-and-drive with Pirelli, the tiremaker showcased its relationship with Lamborghini with a stop at the prestige OEM’s Lamborghini Lounge, a no-frills building tucked inside New York City’s Chelsea District. Inside, it’s where discerning soon-to-be Lamborghini owners can go and customize their vehicles (namely, the Huracán and Aventador) as part of the carmaker’s

Lamborghini Lounge vehicle personalized
Fleet Tire Market to Outpace Overall Tire Market to 2026

Fleet tire consumption is growing along with population and middle-class expansion regardless of the economic and transportation setbacks related to COVID-19. Thanks to the shift in mobility that is taking place to 2026 and beyond, which includes greater efficiencies in commercial transport and the use of car- and ride-sharing fleets for personal transportation, the fleet

Looking for Opportunities Amid Supply Challenges

While the industry continues to battle supply issues, now is a good time to look at other aspects of your shop that you can control.

Forging a Path Forward

The skills we learned from being distanced because of the pandemic will stay with us, but think of it this way: As the world opens up, what opportunities will it offer you?

Forging a Path Ahead

Other Posts

Future Proofing your Business as Vehicle Technology Changes

Most of us are back to living lives that resemble our pre-pandemic selves, but chip shortages persist, and new car production rates still haven’t recovered, with Trading Economics still recording a significant drop in United States car production compared to pre-pandemic rates, and The Alliance for Automotive Innovation recording that North America lost more than

autonomous technology in cars
Finding Your Tire Shop’s Value Proposition

By following a few steps, any growing business in this field, new or old, will be better positioned to determine what their value proposition is, too.

State of the Industry service advisor customer
Waves of Change: Tire Review Makes Staff Changes

Tire Review is accelerating its efforts to keep you engaged, enthusiastic and curious about the growth your business can achieve.

TR Staff 1400
2021 Top Shop Competition Standouts Are the ‘Best of the Best’

These Top Shops lead by example, relentlessly focus on elevating their customers’ service experience, outshine their competitors, stand out in their community and commit to excellence, says Tire Review Editor Mary DellaValle.

Tire Review Top Shop Event