Today’s Civic Lesson - Tire Review Magazine

Today’s Civic Lesson

Perhaps you have heard about the not-too-bright Canadian MP who made some unfortunate passes at jokes during a serious recall over tainted lunch meat.

Our friends at Web site This is True received a little lesson in how Canada’s government works. Compare and contrast…

“"Politically Incorrect", a Premium subscriber in Canada wrote to say that Easter isn’t just an opposition party M.P., he’s Ritz’s official ‘critic’. I wasn’t familiar with that concept, and asked him to explain. Magnus in B.C. did, and it’s so fascinating I’m reproducing it here:

"Easter is indeed an M.P., an elected member of Parliament. As the Agriculture Critic, his job is basically the ‘Anti-Minister’, someone who calls the Agriculture Minister to task for any mistakes that happen under his watch. As a member of an opposition party, that’s his duty to Canada.

"In Canada, we have more parties than in the U.S. — this upcoming election, we’ve actually got five major political parties, all of which are likely to get seats in our House of Commons. We have the Conservatives, a moderately right-wing party; the Liberals, a centrist party; the NDP, a left-wing party; the Bloq Quebecois, a separatist party; and the Green Party, a left-wing party. There are also numerous fringe parties. The party with the most seats names the Prime Minister, the leader of Canada. We’re having an election on October 14. Some call the elections in Canada ‘interesting’; others, a gong show.

"You’ve no doubt noticed that if there are five parties, that means that there’s not always a party with the most seats. In that case, we end up with a ‘minority government’, where any bill passed must have the assent of at least two parties before it can be introduced. It makes for a less efficient, but more balanced, government. Before the election was called, the conservative party held a minority government. We use a ‘first past the post’ election system, where the person with the most votes wins their riding. (That person can, and often does, have less than 50% of the popular vote.) The raw count from those ridings are used to determine the governing party in Canada directly, without the use of an Electoral College.

"There are always opposition parties — the full title is ‘Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition’. As the title implies, their job is to oppose the government in anything they do, and their loyalty to the country is never in question. (I’ve heard that in some countries, questioning the President or the government can bring your loyalty or patriotism into question! What a quirky notion!)

"In the governing party (the one who chooses the Prime Minister) Ministers are appointed. A Minister has a portfolio, which is their job while they’re the Minister. The Industry Minister is in charge of Canada’s Industry; the Agriculture Minister is in charge of Canada’s agriculture, and so forth. They are ultimately responsible for any problems that arise while they’re holding the portfolio. In the case of Gerry Ritz, he’s responsible for the tainted meat from Maple Leaf. The idea is that if they had enacted better laws, the problems would not have happened.

"The opposition party/parties appoint(s) ‘Critics’. For every party and every Minister, there is a Critic. In the case of Gerry Ritz, he’s got three Agriculture Critics watching his every move. It is their duty and privilege to make the Minister answer for any misfortunes, laws, or actions that happen during their term. In the extremely rare case where a party gets an overwhelming lead, they will invite the leaders of the opposition parties to sit in the House and appoint their own members as Critics. This happened once at the provincial level.

"I’m not sure how this will work with another party elected. Perhaps there will be four critics. Nevertheless, the critics are an integral part of Canada’s political system. They make it extremely difficult for the government to get away with anything in secret."

This may be old news for those in a parliamentary system, but it’s completely different from the U.S., where the press — the "Fourth Estate" (or fourth branch of government) — is supposed to do that watchdog function. Sometimes it does it well, and other times …uh…less well. It would be interesting to debate which method works better — so I’ve posted the story and this explanation to my blog, where you can post your comments. The most amusing aspect of this to me: even though it was unknowing, I really was right on about the critic taking work from news people!”

Just thought you’d like to know more about our neighbors.

If you have comments to share, send to me at [email protected].

– Jim Smith

You May Also Like

How to know whether to resurface or replace brake rotors

The rise of front-wheel-drive vehicles in the mid-1970s led to the emergence of hubless or “hat” style rotors.


Remember the island of misfit toys from 1964’s Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer? All those sad toys were thrown away for being not good enough or broken, when in reality all they needed was a little love. Well, just imagine this concept but for brake rotors. Constantly, brake rotors are thrown away to scrap piles. What some technicians may think needs replacement may just need to be resurfaced. Let’s talk about what technicians should look out for before sending brake rotors to the island of misfit parts. 

Hercules Tire reveals spring rebate on five tire lines

From now until May 15, customers who purchase four qualifying Hercules Tires may be eligible to receive up to a $70 rebate.

Michelin leadership talks EVs, sustainability and airless tires

Executives discuss the future of sustainable tire manufacturing, the relationship between EVs and tire waste and what’s next for airless tire technology.

Kenda Tires becomes Cleveland Cavaliers associate partner for NBA playoff games

The tire manufacturer will be advertised on the court, with Kenda-branded rally towels, and will appear during local pre-game programming.

Nokian Tyres releases 2023 sustainability report

Highlights of the company’s sustainability actions in 2023 include a commitment to achieve science-based net-zero emissions by 2050.


Other Posts

Yokohama Rubber’s Advan Sport V107 tires to be used as OE on new Mercedes

The Mercedes-AMG CLE 53 4Matic+ Coupé is being fitted with 265/40ZR19 (102Y) front tires and 295/35ZR19 (104Y) rear tires.

MatraX Tyres on navigating the diverse needs of the U.S. marketplace

We talk about how MatraX Tyres is adapting its products for U.S. customers and the challenges associated with U.S. distribution.

MatraX Tyres on navigating the diverse needs of the U.S. marketplace

We talk about how MatraX Tyres is adapting its products for U.S. customers and the challenges associated with U.S. distribution.

EV tire satisfaction gap widens as wear rates increase, J.D. Power study finds

The J.D. Power study shows that EV owners have similar expectations of tire wear as owners of gas-powered vehicles do.