The Art of Buying Tires: Effective Pricing Strategies for Tire Dealers

The Art of Buying Tires: Effective Pricing Strategies

Many independent dealers are struggling with profitability today, simply focusing on tire sales to increase the bottom line. Yet it all starts with the top line, meaning more sales will result in more profits.

How tire dealers can price tires effectively

Many years ago, when I first started in this business, I was working at the retail counter and asked my regional manager what was the best tire for a vehicle. I expected him to tell me it was the most expensive we had in the lead brand or newest one that was in all the commercials. Instead, he threw me a curve and told me, “The one we have in stock.” He quickly went about his business and left me thinking about it for a while.

Finally, it hit me. Features and benefits were important, and the price had to be within the customer’s budget, but if we didn’t have the tire on the shelf, we lost the sale. Granted, times were a bit simpler back then. There were fewer sizes, dealers usually only carried one (maybe two) brands, and we had several hundred tires in inventory. We used inventory cards and went through invoices daily to keep an accurate account of what was in stock. Tires were ordered as needed and we would take advantage of specials and seasonal trends to make sure we had the tire in stock to make the sale. The older dealers reading this will remember those days. It took time and every invoice was marked with a ‘P’ to ensure inventory was posted and accurate.

Times have sure changed. Today, we have computers on the counter with a wealth of information at our fingertips. Most dealers have a multi-brand approach with tires, and dealers have access to virtually every brand manufactured within a few hours (or a couple of days in some rural areas). Most distributors have an online portal where a salesperson can quickly look up what tire fits a vehicle and/or what the price is for the requested tire size. If the dealer has taken the time to set up a profile within the distributor’s system, the retail sales price including installation will be displayed to make it easy to quote a price. Press the order button, and the tires will be delivered at or darn near a certain time every day, sometimes twice or more the same day. Efficiencies have made our lives easier, and most dealers today inventory few, if any, tires. In some cases, retailers have numerous online portals on their computer screens for several area distributors, and order tires based on delivery times during the day from different companies so they can come close to “having the tire in stock” when the customer needs it.

If you compare the two scenarios above, few would argue that the process today is very efficient, and I would agree. What I don’t agree with is that so many dealers have fallen into a comfort zone. Making it easier can cost you money. Dealers don’t take time to really evaluate their tire needs, and the computer screen has become their product screen. Inventory, or “the one we have in stock,” has been replaced by the distributor that can deliver the tire at the time that best fits the customer’s need. I’m not saying that it’s a bad thing, but I believe that many dealers are missing opportunities to increase sales and profits, which is contributing to the struggle of many independent tire dealers. It’s what I call the “Lost Art of Buying.”

Many independent dealers are struggling with profitability today, and simply focusing on tire sales will increase the bottom line. It all starts with the top-line, meaning more sales will result in more profits.

Over the years, many dealers have “left” the tire business to focus more on service. Sure, they still sell tires, but the lure of higher gross profit tickets has become a priority. Again, I’m not saying that’s a bad thing, but as vehicles become more technical and the labor pool grows shallower, this can really come back to bite you if you are not able to service the vehicles in the future. If you’ve let the competition establish themselves as the place to buy tires, it may be an uphill fight to gain customers back when you need to build the business. Tires have always driven service sales, but that doesn’t seem to work the other way quite as well.

A good friend in this business tells the story of a friend who bought a restaurant franchise specializing in steaks. It was a proven model that worked successfully. He draws a comparison to the steak being the tires, and the liquor in the bar as being the service. When there was the proper mix and focus everything worked well. His friend saw heavy profits in the bar so he started focusing efforts to building the bar business and lost focus on providing a delicious steak. Over time, the restaurant failed because people stopped coming in for food, and lost interest in just having a cocktail in the bar. The lesson here is to make sure there is an equal focus on both tires and service.

There are three key pieces that I believe will make selling tires profitable for your business: 1) Effective pricing; 2) Building the proper product screen, and 3) Making tires a priority with your sales team.

In this first article of the series, we’ll discuss No. 1, effective pricing. Efficiencies have made the entire tire-ordering process a lot simpler, but dealers can easily overlook several basics that will result in improvements in sales and profitability. This is the comfort zone I referred to earlier, and here are several suggestions you may want to consider.

Update Your Online Profile

When was the last time you updated your online profile with your distributors? I’ve asked this question of dealers across the country, and so often the answer is “I can’t remember,” or “when the distributor’s salesperson set up the profile.” This can be a huge factor on both the sales and the profit side of the equation.

Think about when a customer calls in for a price. Your salesperson opens the portal and presents a quote based on your profile. The marketplace changes, your buying price from the distributor changes regularly, installation prices change and competition may get more aggressive. If you are working from dated information, you may not be competitive and you could lose the sale.

On the profit side, have you looked at the selling prices with your competition, including online? Pricing is always a dynamic situation and if not reviewed constantly, you may find that you are selling too cheap and leaving money on the table – or priced too high and losing sales.

Is your sales price established based on a “dollar” or “percentage” markup? I would argue that you are leaving money on the table if you use a dollar markup. Dealers have told me that they will just add a $20 dollar bill as an example to the cost to make things easy for the sales team. On a $100 tire, many dealers will argue that is equal to a 20% gross profit, which it is not. Granted, it may be easier for busy counter people to calculate, but over time the pennies add up and can make a huge difference to your bottom line. Here’s a quick example, comparing adding a $20 dollar bill versus setting the price based on a 20% gross profit:

ire buying and selling gross markup and profit

In the simplistic example above, one could argue that on a $75 tire, adding a $20 dollar bill puts more money in your pocket and I would agree. But on a $125 tire the 20% mark-up puts substantially more in the gross profit bucket. The online portal with your distributor can make those calculations for you. Training your team on how to calculate gross profit percentages and, more importantly, utilizing the POS system that you are using will also help.

Another suggestion would be to look at the profile by brand or segment and move away from a “one-size-fits-all” approach to pricing. Maybe on the entry-level products you want to be a bit more competitive and work on a little less gross profit to attract customers. On other segments you may want to make a few percent more. Either way, a more focused effort will produce increases.

Carrying an Inventory

Are you taking advantage of buying specials offered by the manufacturers and distributors? This is where the focus on the Art of Buying can make a big difference in the bottom line. In some cases, this requires inventorying tires, which can be a good thing, especially on entry level tires where many buyers want the tire now. If you could save an additional $5 per tire on buying 100 units, that’s $500 to your bottom line. If you could do that every other month, that’s an additional $3,000 in the bank at the end of the year. There are dealers over the years that have made substantial money by buying at the right time and stocking tires. They don’t create a big stir in the market, the tires are blended into the sales mix and the additional profits are realized over time.

An easy trap to fall into is to take the additional $5 special and just pass it along to the customer. That may be necessary in some cases to be competitive or when you want to increase sales. A suggestion here is to ask your supplier for the special to be a credit at month’s end. This ensures that the additional discount or special goes into the bank and not automatically passed along to the customer. By taking advantage of the offers when presented, it becomes a management decision based on which is more important at that point in time.

There is no exact science to how to run a successful tire and service business. There are so many factors that affect the outcome. These will vary by market, by the owner’s focus, by competitive situations and many other elements. Tires have become a commodity in so many markets, and having an exclusive tire line these days to provide additional profit opportunities is rare. In subsequent articles, we’ll address the other key pieces to selling tires – the Product Screen and Making Tires a Priority.

You May Also Like

Pirelli equips its P Zero Elect tire on the Hyundai IONIQ 5 N

In a two-year collaboration with Hyundai, Pirelli said it developed a custom version of its P Zero tire for the EV.


Pirelli has developed a tailor-made version of its P Zero tire as OE for the Hyundai IONIQ 5 N. In a two-year collaboration with Hyundai, Pirelli said it developed a tire that meets the requirements of the EV, which was tested on the Nürburgring circuit in Germany to test its performance and consistency under extreme driving conditions.

Price Check: Tire Replacements Across the US

Compare your tire replacement pricing, including mounting, balancing and TPMS service, to national averages.

Avoid wheel damage installing tires
Eight Great Practices for Creating a Winning Team Culture

In your quest to be the absolute best tire/auto service business you can possibly be, you can have a beautiful facility, state-of-the-art equipment and all the amenities to enrich your customer’s experience, but if don’t have a great, “Winning Team” culture, then you still don’t have a truly great company. Related Articles – What Your

What Your Credit Score Can do to Your Business

If you want to explain your business in the future, one thing you need to prioritize is your credit score. Having bad business credit can negatively impact your shop in many ways – from causing difficulties securing financing to getting approved for a lease. Related Articles – Rising Gas Prices Make Tire Distributors Rethink Pricing,

Credit Score Business
Ferrante: What I’ve Learned From Listening to 100,000 Sales Calls

Back in 2014, I authored an article titled, “Are Your Tire/Auto Service Salespeople ‘Winging It’ on the Phone?” At the time the article was published, my Pinnacle Performance Training team and I had evaluated approximately 25,000 sales calls between tire/auto service sales staff and prospective customers. In May of this year, we reached a milestone


Other Posts

CMA, Double Coin unveil REM-26 steer and REM-4 drive tires for airport ground support applications

The tires are designed to allow maximum endurance in the airport ground support environment.

Toyo Tires upgrades compound for M171+, M671A+ and M677+ truck tires

The upgrades will be applied to 14 sizes, including 22.5-in. for M171+ and M671A+, and both 22.5-in. and 24.5-in. for M677+.

Radar Tires releases Dimax winter, all-weather tire lines

Both ranges have been tested in multiple winter and summer weather conditions in collaboration with UTAC at its laboratories.

Continental Tire opens new Retread Solutions Center in South Carolina

The company hopes to uncover new improvements and technologies to innovate the retread process.