Should We Be Surprised? - Tire Review Magazine

Should We Be Surprised?

"The parties agree that no party ... shall make any further public statements regarding the adversary proceeding or the matters addressed herein, except in so far as any party is required to publicly disclose any information pursuant to any statutory obligation..."

Should We Be Surprised?

"The parties agree that no party … shall make any further public statements regarding the adversary proceeding or the matters addressed herein, except in so far as any party is required to publicly disclose any information pursuant to any statutory obligation…"

That was part of a 13-page binding settlement document issued by U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Susan Sonderby, closing the book on Penske Auto Centers (PAC) and the relationship between Penske Corp. and Kmart.

These former mates might have agreed to public silence after a very noisy divorce, but there is a textbook lesson here that we can all learn from. Some of you larger dealers, in particular, may want to take a few notes.

If one of your core business assumptions is that customers will come simply because of your brand name or on the strength of whatever brand you represent, think again. That assumption might bring failure before you’ve even gotten out of the gate.

Over nearly seven years, Roger Penske shed some 300 stores, pumped tens of millions of dollars into his PAC enterprise, and still enthusiastically spoke of growth and expansion. As only my colleague could put it, "it’s been like watching a sailor bailing rising waters from a sinking life boat with a teacup."

One year ago, Jim Wheat, president and CEO of PAC, spoke glowingly about Penske’s new long-term agreement with Kmart and the "unique marketing advantage" Penske enjoys by having its PACs located at Kmarts. "It certainly offers us excellent exposure to Kmart’s customer base."

Last fall, an even more enthusiastic Wheat unveils PAC’s plans to add 30-40 new stores in 2002, including a handful of stand-alone locations.

Five months later, Kmart files Chapter 11 and closes 284 of its stores, forcing PAC to close 63 of its locations. Wheat says that impact on PAC will be "minimal," and enthusiastically states that the remaining 563 PACs are "strong and performing well."

Not 30 days later, and with no warning, PAC ceases to exist. All locations are shut down, and most are gutted by the time Kmart gets an injunction the next day. By then, Judge Sonderby, who is overseeing Kmart’s bankruptcy proceedings, has little choice but to "negotiate" a divorce settlement.

Despite annual sales dropping from an estimated $400 million back in 1995 to under $300 million in 2001, Penske kept insisting that PAC would grow. But over the same span, PAC never averaged more than $500,000 in annual sales per location. In comparison, the typical tire dealer averaged $1.4 million per location in 2000, according to Tire Review’s Tire Dealer Profile Study.

Other than throwing money at the problem – and Wheat’s cheerleading – neither Kmart nor Penske did much to help the PAC cause.

Kmart’s long-rumored bankruptcy was the capstone to 15 years of lost focus and misguided assumptions about both its competition and consumers. Not to mention a series of eye-off-the-ball expansions – Builders Square, Office Max, Borders, and Sports Authority – that either failed or had to be spun off.

Roger Penske was the polar opposite. Single-minded focus brought him 11 Indy 500 wins, a profitable chassis-design business and valuable business connections. He parlayed those into a successful a truck leasing business and car dealerships, and the revival and profitable sale of Detroit Diesel.

By late 1995, when Penske came to the expected rescue with $112 million for his 64% share in PAC, Kmart had botched its auto service business so badly that it was financially draining and faced numerous well-publicized consumer lawsuits.

No matter that Roger had never been in retailing, and had never sold a single tire. Never mind that Kmart was losing relevance, and its auto service efforts brought consumer mistrust.

Everyone was convinced that Kmart’s market presence – its size and its brand – would drive millions of consumers into PAC bays.

Everyone expected Roger’s name to magically cast the blue light (sorry, I couldn’t help myself) of success on the retail tire and auto service business.

While PAC suffered from many maladies, what really did it in was blind faith in the supposed power of "brand." Because for all the work that goes into building a successful brand, even more must go into maintaining its integrity and value.

So, in this world of consolidation and contraction, if one of your core assumptions is that customers will come simply because of you – or your brand name – think again.

You May Also Like

Tesla Model 3 TPMS service

Resetting and programming TPMS sensors for a Tesla is a lot like any other vehicle, and the challenge is still the same: keeping the light off.

bendpakEVgarageTPMS-1400

One of the first items to be replaced on any Tesla model are the tires. This is due to tire wear from the instant torque of the electric motor. When replacing the tires, you will have to service the TPMS sensors. Tesla has used Baolong (from 2012 to 2014), Continental (from 2014 to 2020) and a proprietary sensor that uses Bluetooth. For 2021, the Model Y started to use a sensor that communicates using Bluetooth protocols. Not much is known about the new system except that the sensors are currently available only through Tesla.

TIA’s Advanced Farm Tire Service training to take place in June

The training class for technicians in the agricultural and farm tire industries is set to take place June 11-14.

TIA_training-
Three spark plug service and replacement tips

How to avoid and overcome roadblocks that may come up during the removal or installation of spark plugs.

Continental-sparkplug
Maxxis-sponsored athletes make podium, overall top 10 at Mint 400

Maxxis athletes Michael McFayden, Ethan Ebert and Trey Gibbs had podium finishes at the Mint 400 on Maxxis RAZR XT tires.

2024-mint400-maxxis
Sun Auto Tire reveals winner of Ford Bronco Sport giveaway

Lowell Anderson entered the giveaway at his local Sun Auto Tire & Service store while receiving a routine oil change.

Sun-Auto-Bronco-giveaway

Other Posts

Nokian Tyres holds bracket challenge on worst roads in North America

In 2023, the tiremaker’s audience voted Quebec as the province or state with the worst road conditions on the continent.

Pothole-Protection-from-Nokian-Tyres
Hankook to display its iON tire lineup at this year’s Electrify Expo

Hankook will also sponsor Electrify Expo’s Demo District, designed to provide hands-on experiences with EVs.

Hankook-iON-Electrify-Expo
Gallery: 2024 Big O Tires conference and convention

Highlights from this year’s Big O Tires conference and convention, featuring a general session, trade show and breakout sessions.

Gary-Skidmore
Bridgestone’s Firestone Liberia rubber farm receives ISCC Plus recognition

According to Bridgestone, its Liberia facility earned the ISCC Plus certification for its efforts in reducing environmental impacts.

Firestone_Liberia