Rush to Tire Fuel Efficiency With Contradictory Tasks, Unexpected Options - Tire Review Magazine

Rush to Tire Fuel Efficiency With Contradictory Tasks, Unexpected Options

In the rush to make tires more environmentally friendly (or, if you want to be cynical, less environmentally unfriendly), few consider the plight of the designers of ultra-high performance tires.
Soybeans are a popular foodstuff for the health-conscious, and soybean oil often is used in popular salad dressings. Now tiremakers are looking at employing soybean oil as a replacement for petro-based oil in tire production.
These brilliant engineers are charged with accomplishing contradictory tasks. They must retain or, ideally, expand the traction UHP buyers seek, while reducing rolling resistance, limiting the use of petroleum products and toxic chemicals, and cutting the tire’s weight – while keeping retail price the same.

It’s like a football coach telling a player: “Make more tackles, but don’t hit the other players hard. Also, sweat less while running faster, and give us a rebate on your salary. And stop ripping up the grass and wearing out your uniform.”

All the tire companies I contacted were closed-mouth about this topic. None of the tire companies returned our emails. The public relations representative for one company did, but only to tell us that they wouldn’t tell us anything.

From a journalist’s view, that means I hit the target in the center of the X. From a reader’s standpoint, that means all I can do is speculate and use the little information published on tiremaker websites. I guess they don’t want to help you help consumers.

As journalists aren’t really all­owed to speculate, my guess is that tire companies are having a devil of a time retaining UHP grip while meeting “environmental goals” and maintaining costs. It also means the car companies are probably flogging tiremakers to gain an additional 0.25 mile per gallon for their hot new supercar.

Low rolling resistance is the hallmark of eco-friendly tires. Traditionally, improving rolling resistance a little tiny bit REALLY hurts traction, especially damp traction. I’ve seen wet stopping distances grow by 30 or more feet between an otherwise equal low rolling resistance tire and one made conventionally. Some makers have tried to break the trade-off by introducing silica to the recipe. If I’m not mistaken, though, this increases cost and introduces sand fragments into the air.

Testing For LRR
A word about low rolling resistance. Some tiremakers claim as much as an 8% improvement in fuel mileage compared to a) previous models, b) other of their tire lines, or c) a competitor’s product that could be considered head-to-head competition…or not. Until there are realistic, common test requirements, none of these purported improvements can be proven or agreed.

Regardless, when it comes to these claims, a tiremaker is going to have to open up and show a real-world difference. While working for a tire company, I attempted to set up a real-world demonstration to illustrate low rolling resistance. I tried coast downs of several des­criptions and a Soap Box Derby-style start. Nothing was repeatable, much less robust enough to show outsiders.

The coast downs appeared to be more a test of the sensitivity of the GPS-based speedometer. The gravity attempt appeared to be impacted by the wind. So the results were random. Sometimes the low rolling resistance tire coasted further, sometimes the high rolling resistance tire coasted further.

Next Requirement
Next, the UHP designers must reduce weight. One of the easiest ways to improve traction of any tire is to fit it into the upper left corner of the Tire and Rim Association dimensional windows: That is, make it as tall and wide as is all­owed while still being able to retain its nominal size. That option no longer is available. A lighter tire im­proves rolling resistance and saving a quarter ounce here and a quarter ounce there might do something. But I don’t think so.

One tiremaker has an eco tire with a “reduced hysteresis” sidewall. I keep getting hysteresis backward, but I know that hysteresis like a Superball offers less grip and better rolling resistance, while hysteresis like Silly Putty offers more grip and worse rolling resistance. Regardless, that doesn’t seem to be in the UHP tire designer’s favor.

Eliminating aromatic oils has long been a goal. And using less petroleum means a lower carbon footprint. But less petroleum increases the difficulty of making any tire.

Companies are trying everything from oil from orange peels to sunflower oil to dandelion oil to soybean oil – and I’m sure further research efforts will uncover other potential resources.

If anyone’s had a true groundbreaking breakthrough, they’re not talking about it. In fairness, it app­ears that everything is being looked at, considered, fiddled with and added to the potential mix.

Not trying to be a fuddy-duddy here, but tires have been made the way they are for a very good reason, and tiremakers (and their lawyers) will be very deliberate in testing and evaluating new or replacement compounds, chemicals or processes to produce any tire – let alone rush to the eco bandwagon.

Designers are even trying to increase the use of natural rubber, because it is a renewable resource. Of course, if any of these renewables proves to be a miracle cure, we may find ourselves literally changing the landscape to grow more of whatever the cure is – and damaging our environment in other ways as a result.

Dear UHP tire designers, I don’t envy your task.

You May Also Like

Bridgestone Launches Potenza Race Tire

The Potenza Race tire is Bridgestone’s first-ever dedicated replacement tire for track days.


Bridgestone Americas has launched the latest addition to its ultra-high-performance (UHP) Potenza lineup: the Bridgestone Potenza Race tire. The manufacturer said the tire was created for track enthusiasts looking to perform and "push the limits." The all-new Potenza Race is a semi-slick tire homologated for public roads, but with performance focused on track days, Bridgestone says.

Winter Tire Market Flat, But EV-Specific Products Bring Opportunity

Affected by pandemic supply chain disruptions and the uptick in sales of all-weather tires, the winter tire market in the U.S. has been largely flat in recent years. Despite the expectation that this will continue, tire dealers in snowy regions like the northern U.S. and Canada still should plan ahead to meet consumer demand in

Hankook Tire Launches iON Evo EV Tires in the US

Hankook Tire America launched the company’s first tires specifically designed for electric vehicles (EVs) in the US. The iON evo AS and iON evo AS SUV are built with Hankook’s “EVolution” technology, which focuses on tread wear, noise reduction and unique grip performance for EVs, said the company. Related Articles – Michelin Introduces New Radial

Tires for Pickup Trucks are Picking Up Speed

In recent years, the pickup truck market has grown in more ways than one. While the number of vehicles in the segment continues to climb, the versatility expected of pickups is also on the rise. Related Articles – Vredestein Enters LT Segment in N.A. With Pinza A/T Launch – Sneak Peek: Kenda Tire’s Next-Gen Mud-Terrain

Vredestein Enters LT Segment in N.A. With Pinza A/T Launch

While the Vredestein Pinza A/T aims to appeal to SUV and light-truck drivers in North America, Apollo Tyres says the brand will carry on its European legacy.

Vredestein Pinza A/T Apollo Tyres

Other Posts

Bridgestone Designs New Tire for Straddle Containers

Bridgestone said the VPCS radial tire is currently available in two sizes: 450/95R25 and 480/95R25.

Tires for Fast-Growing SUV/CUV Segment Must Meet Versatile Consumer Demands

Both OE fitments and replacement tires have shifted to increased rim diameters from what was standard just a decade ago.

Maxam Tire Expands its Radial Construction Series

Designed with steel belts, the company said the radial design provides additional protection from punctures.

Bridgestone Develops Tire Using 75% Recycled, Renewable Materials

Bridgestone said the new tire is the first street tire to use natural rubber derived from the guayule desert shrub.

Bridgestone 75 percent sustainable tires