NHTSA Center Stage in Senate Oversight Committee Hearing - Tire Review Magazine

NHTSA Center Stage in Senate Oversight Committee Hearing

The U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee’s Subcommittee on Oversight, Federal Rights and Agency Action took shots at NHTSA during a Nov. 25 hearing, with some members calling the agency ineffective.

They held a hearing titled, “Updated: Justice Denied: Rules Delayed on Auto Safety and Mental Health.”

The auto safety-oriented hearing featured a range of witnesses, including law professors, former legislators and Clarence Ditlow, executive director at the Center of Auto Safety in Washington, D.C.

The hearing discussed NHTSA’s shortcomings as a rulemaking agency. Some defended the agency, while others argued that it has failed to do what it was originally designed to do.

Most obviously on that list, from a tire industry standpoint, is the well overdue, final rulemaking on the tire testing, labeling and consumer education program that became law with the Energy Bill of 2007.   

According to witness Thomas McGarity of the University of Texas law school, “NHTSA has effectively given up on rulemaking unless specifically required by statute, focusing instead on its statutory power to force the recall of motor vehicles that contain ‘defects’ related to safety performance. The move away from rulemaking to adjudication gives the agency the flexibility to allow policies to evolve through the gradual process of stare decisis.”           

Ditlow voiced similar opinions toward NHTSA throughout his testimony. He said: “NHTSA is a wonderful agency with a vital mission but it is woefully underfunded … During the first five years after its creation in 1966, NHTSA issued more safety standards than it did in the next 40 years. Many of the original standards such as seat back strength and head restraints are woefully out of date. With rare exception, revision of the original standards or issuance of major new standards came from Congressional mandates. Today, standards issued by NHTSA on its own tend to be relatively minor or without significant industry opposition such as low-speed vehicles, wheel chair lifts and alternative fuel systems.”            

Ditlow also expressed concern about the lack of initiative NHTSA has been taking. “Failure to issue effective rules result in large recalls that cost the auto industry lost profits and the public lost lives,” he said.

On the other side, Cary Coglianese of the University of Pennsylvania law school, defended NHTSA. “Despite widespread acceptance by virtually every major scholar of administrative law, the claim that NHTSA has retreated from rulemaking and shifted instead to recalls does not bear the weight of scrutiny. NHTSA has continued to issue a substantial body of new regulations even in wake of judicial losses that have been thought to have been paralyzing to the agency. Its recalls did not increase in the aftermath of either the agency’s losses in rulemaking challenges or its wins in recall litigation.

“When a broad sweep of NHTSA’s litigated cases is considered, it is clear that NHTSA has not been beleaguered by high levels of judicial invalidations,” he continued. “The way that NHTSA rules declined after an initial flurry of regulatory activity appears more likely explained by the life cycle of implementing a new statute, diminished public support for auto safety regulation, or changing patterns in the agency’s operations and research budget.”            

You May Also Like

Life for Tyres Group Limited to build U.S. facility in Louisiana

The recycling and manufacturing plant, L4T Louisiana LLC, will convert end-of-life tires into high-quality sustainable commodities.


Life for Tyres Group Limited (L4T), an end-of-life tire recycling company based in Europe with manufacturing facilities for sustainable commodities, revealed it will invest $46 million to establish its first U.S. processing facility on 10 acres at the Port of South Louisiana. The recycling and manufacturing plant, L4T Louisiana LLC, will convert end-of-life tires into high-quality sustainable commodities such as advanced biofuel feedstock, recovered carbon black and scrap steel, the company said. L4T said it expects to create 46 direct new jobs in St. John the Baptist Parish. Louisiana Economic Development estimates the project will result in 151 indirect new jobs, for a total of 197 potential new jobs in the Southeast region.

GRI showcased specialty tires at this year’s FIMA Show

GRI’s participation at the show included an unveiling of a range of tires for tractors, construction machines and skid steer equipment.

Trelleborg to showcase tires at LogiMat 2024

Trelleborg will display its XP1000, XP900 and XP800 tires at at LogiMat 2024.

TIA, USTMA form the Tire Recycling Foundation

Central to the foundation’s goal is the ambition to achieve 100% recycling of end-of-life tires in sustainable markets.

Yokohama Rubber reveals three-year management plan to achieve ‘hockey stick’ sales growth by 2027

The company said it will implement production strategies based on a motto of “low cost, speedy development of quality products.”


Other Posts

Bridgestone to withdraw from commercial tire business in China

Due to factors such as market dynamics and competitive advantage, Bridgestone (China) Investment Co. (BSCN) will cease production and sales of TBR tires.

bridgestone china
Kumho Tire USA names new VP of marketing

In her new role, Jessica Egerton will develop and execute integrated marketing and brand awareness programming for Kumho Tire USA.

2024 OTR Conference addresses safety, industry growth, training

The 69th OTR Tire Conference was highlighted by the creation of the Tire Recycling Foundation, safety, tire chains, retreading and more.

CMA, Double Coin appoint new regional sales manager

Patrick Etheridge, a Marine Corps combat veteran, will serve as regional sales manager for the mid-south/Rocky Mountain region.