Has Apollo-Cooper Battle Been Fueled by Investment Bankers? - Tire Review Magazine

Has Apollo-Cooper Battle Been Fueled by Investment Bankers?

Writing on Reuters Breakingviews, corporate finance columnist Una Galani draws attention to how financial institutions contributed towards the current tensions between Apollo Tyres and Cooper Tire & Rubber Co.

She opines that Apollo’s move to renegotiate its Cooper acquisition deal and seek a buying price less than the $2.5 billion originally offered was pushed by attempts from Apollo’s lenders to extricate themselves from the takeover agreement.

“E-mails shown in court reveal lenders to Apollo Tyres have been looking for a way out of the debt-financed takeover of its U.S. rival and pressured the Indian company to renegotiate the $2.5 billion deal,” writes Galani. “Banks appear keen to limit their exposure while avoiding blame for pulling the plug.”

Apollo shareholders and investors were quick to question the high leverage involved in the acquisition of Cooper and the potential future impact this may have on margins. On the very day the company announced its planned acquisition of Cooper, shares in Apollo Tyres fell up to 21% in value. In the weeks that followed, several institutional investors reportedly spoke with Apollo management and implored them to reconsider the deal.

Galani notes that Indian stockbrokerage Kotak Securities calculated Apollo’s EBITDA margin would be (based on the original offered purchase price) around 300 basis points higher than its interest payments following the acquisition.

“That’s a thin cushion in the volatile tire-making business,” she comments. She adds that problems at the Cooper Chengshan Tire operation in China further undermined Apollo’s plan to repay the debt it would take on; and while under the merger agreement this doesn’t give Apollo grounds to walk away from the deal, Galani says lenders privately discussed whether the Indian tiremaker could “wriggle off the hook or negotiate a lower price.” She makes particular reference to an e-mail written by Morgan Stanley managing director William Dotson on Sept. 14.

Dotson wrote of a possible scenario where Apollo allows negotiations with United Steelworkers representatives to remain open until the deal’s expiry date; he allegedly recommended “watching the clock run out (on the deal) to the end of the year.”

Two weeks later, Sumit Dayal, Standard Chartered’s global head of strategic finance, is said to have suggested Apollo negotiate a lower price for Cooper and warned that the deal should not be closed until issues with Cooper Chengshan Tire were resolved. Galani reports that “Morgan Stanley, Standard Chartered and Apollo all declined to comment” regarding these alleged communications.

So far the lender banks have sat on the sidelines while Apollo and Cooper slog it out, however the Breakingviews columnist believes they may soon take on a more high profile role. When Cooper’s appeal hearing takes place in the Delaware Supreme Court next month, a ruling will be made on whether Apollo should be compelled to close the deal at its agreed terms. The lender banks must then decide whether they will honor their commitments or move to protect themselves from what they see as a risky loan. Galani’s view is that “whatever the outcome, the courtroom revelations don’t show them in a good light.”  (Tyres & Accessories)

You May Also Like

Yokohama Rubber reveals 2024 motorsports activity plan

Yokohama said participation in motorsports activities is crucial to its efforts to strengthen the Advan and GeoLandar brands.

Yokohama-Nitrocross

Yokohama Rubber revealed its motorsports activity plan for 2024. The company said participation in motorsports activities is crucial to its efforts to strengthen the Advan and GeoLandar brands and is again participating in a wide variety of motorsports events around the globe, from top-category to grassroots events.

Yokohama Rubber will again supply its Advan tires to many teams participating in motorsports events, such as Japan’s Super GT, the Nürburgring 24-Hour Race and the Pikes Peak International Hill Climb. Yokohama Rubber’s GeoLandar tires will be supplied to teams participating in off-road races in North America and Asia, including the Baja 1000, King of the Hammers, the Mint 400 and the Asia Cross Country Rally.

TIA’s Advanced Farm Tire Service training to take place in June

The training class for technicians in the agricultural and farm tire industries is set to take place June 11-14.

TIA_training-
Maxxis-sponsored athletes make podium, overall top 10 at Mint 400

Maxxis athletes Michael McFayden, Ethan Ebert and Trey Gibbs had podium finishes at the Mint 400 on Maxxis RAZR XT tires.

2024-mint400-maxxis
Sun Auto Tire reveals winner of Ford Bronco Sport giveaway

Lowell Anderson entered the giveaway at his local Sun Auto Tire & Service store while receiving a routine oil change.

Sun-Auto-Bronco-giveaway
Nokian Tyres holds bracket challenge on worst roads in North America

In 2023, the tiremaker’s audience voted Quebec as the province or state with the worst road conditions on the continent.

Pothole-Protection-from-Nokian-Tyres

Other Posts

Gallery: 2024 Big O Tires conference and convention

Highlights from this year’s Big O Tires conference and convention, featuring a general session, trade show and breakout sessions.

Gary-Skidmore
Bridgestone’s Firestone Liberia rubber farm receives ISCC Plus recognition

According to Bridgestone, its Liberia facility earned the ISCC Plus certification for its efforts in reducing environmental impacts.

Firestone_Liberia
Ascenso Tires adds new OEM sales manager

Douglas Duesing has more than ten years of experience working in agriculture, construction and mining OEMs.

Ascenso-Douglas-Duesing-1400
Nexen Tire Motorsports drivers earn top placements at King of the Hammers

Nexen Tire Motorsports partnered with drivers across a variety of racing series both on- and off-road, including King of the Hammers.

Nexen-KOH