Goodyear-Cooper Deal: Benefits, Challenges & What’s Ahead

Goodyear-Cooper Deal: Benefits, Challenges & What’s Ahead

While the market reacted favorably to the transaction, questions remain about how these two companies will integrate and the long-term benefits for both—and dealers—down the line.

When Goodyear announced plans to acquire Cooper Tire Feb. 22, both companies’ stocks went up as officials touted the synergies that would be achieved from the combined company. This was a good sign, according to market analysts, and they believe that over time all levels of the industry will benefit from the two joining forces.

“Scale matters in an ever-evolving, more competitive market,” say Phillip Kane and Steve Rathbone, Senior Advisor and Managing Director with Stout, a global investment bank and advisory firm. “The synergies [between the two companies] are attainable. The equity markets are blessing this transaction based on price activity.”

While the market reacted favorably to the transaction, questions remain about how these two companies will integrate and the long-term benefits for both—and dealers—down the line. Tire Review spoke with financial and industry analysts to get their take on the advantages, the challenges and what’s ahead for these two Ohio tire giants.

Good Timing

The first advantage of the transaction was the timing, industry analysts say. With Cooper’s strong balance sheet, a strong equity bull market for M&A activity and low cost and high availability of debt financing, Goodyear acted at the right time, Rathbone and Kane say.

Cooper had fully exited its targeted private label portion of the business and built up new customer relationships and channels, such as Wal-Mart, says James Picariello, equity research analyst at KeyBanc Capital Markets. The tire industry is also grappling with a dynamic trade environment, leading tiremakers to increase domestic production capacity. Those with more North American-based manufacturing sources are slated to benefit.

“If you look at the average tariff rate (approx. 30%) and the widespread impact, almost 30% of the market is affected. As soon as those tariffs took hold in early January, I viewed Cooper as a potential takeout target,” Picariello says, nodding to Cooper’s strength in domestic manufacturing and its net cash balance sheet. “These two companies stand to benefit the most from the tariff environment. Together, as a combined force, they can really gain market share and pull-through price. And, I imagine Goodyear would much rather have Cooper in-house as opposed to strengthening a competitor.”

In addition, Rathbone and Kane say manufacturers have been consolidating, yet also adding capacity, in the last five to 10 years due to size complexity and the lack of available domestic manufacturing sources. With added scale and product offerings, Goodyear stands to remain competitive alongside industry peers.

“We don’t believe we’ll see consolidation of plants in the U.S.,” Rathbone and Kane say. “We see this as a move by Goodyear to recognize it needs more capacity, not less.”

The Challenge of Synergies

Both Goodyear and Cooper executives touted the synergies the companies have, which is expected to yield $165 million in savings over two years. These are in the areas of sales and administrative expenses, including redundancy at the corporate level; R&D; procurement of raw materials, such as carbon black and natural rubber; and logistics and distribution costs, Picariello says.

However, the challenge is that these cost-savings will only happen if the synergies are realized, says Dr. Gregory Jonas, senior associate dean of academics and graduate programs at the Weatherhead School of Management at Case Western Reserve University.

“The number one reason given for business combinations, whether they’re acquisitions or mergers, is synergies—not market share, not product expansion,” he said. “The challenge is if we look across acquisitions over time, as well as through my personal experience, it’s really hard for companies to realize those synergies. It’s pretty easy to map out what should happen, but the reality is always tougher.”

At face value, Jonas said the combined company will put Goodyear in “a better position in the business that they know and understand.” The company will also be larger, which means it will have greater negotiating power and a larger geographic footprint. Both companies also claim to have common leadership styles and corporate culture, which should make it easier to integrate and realize those synergies.

“The more complex the organization is, the longer it will take,” Jonas cautioned. “[With] companies this size, if the integration went really smoothly and they had a great plan and they were very efficient in implementing it, it would still be two to three years at least. And, of course, you can realize synergies along the way.”

Rathbone and Kane agreed that “the key to attaining real synergies” is in managing Cooper’s integration into the Goodyear framework.

“Cooper has done a good job managing costs historically, which can be a good thing for Goodyear longer term,” they said. “A larger, streamlined, efficient and more profitable Goodyear will obviously have a positive impact on the brand and the company globally.”

Next Steps

While the transaction still needs to pass regulatory measures, Picariello and Jonas believe no antitrust concerns will surface.

“Competition is viewed as a good thing, but one would hope the SEC (Securities & Exchange Commission) will look at the market, not just based on the U.S., but on a global scale,” Jonas said. “On a global scale, it’s hard to argue that this [combined company] would cause competition problems since a lot of the brands that Goodyear is competing against globally, like Michelin and Bridgestone, are already in the U.S. They’re part of the competitive landscape. So, this would just make Goodyear more able to compete with those other brands.”

Picariello added that Bridgestone and Michelin also each have mid-to-high teens market share in the U.S., respectively. The combined company of Goodyear and Cooper will result in having low-20% U.S. market share, and further solidifies Goodyear’s No. 3 position globally.

Jonas said while the market reacted favorably to the announcement of the transaction, the actual buyout price will depend on Goodyear’s stock price when the deal closes, which is slated for the second half of 2021.

“If Goodyear stock goes up more, then it’s an even better deal for Cooper shareholders,” he said, adding that it’s difficult to predict the market’s reaction. “It’s purely a matter of investor perceptions.”

You May Also Like

Apollo Tires debuts marketing campaign for longhaul truck tires at TMC

This campaign comes one year after Apollo Tires debuted its long-haul truck tire range at the TMC Expo.

Apollo-Smart-Tires-campaign

Apollo Tires US debuted a new integrated marketing campaign titled ‘Smart Tires for Not Smart Roads’ at the TMC Expo in New Orleans, LA from March 4-7. This campaign comes a year after Apollo Tires debuted its long-haul truck tire range at the TMC Expo.

The campaign was shot in California City and Lake Tahoe, CA and begins by showcasing a variety of road conditions that long-haul truck drivers are no stranger to, including potholes, cracked roads and roads covered in snow and rain and how Apollo long-haul "smart tires" stand up to any test, the company said.

Bridging the past and present: Totten Tire may be Birch Run’s best kept secret in tires

The single-location shop has always been able to draw the business it needs to keep busy, keep customers happy, and keep true to its roots.

K&M-Totten-Tire-Owners-1400
Pilot to add 30 Southern Tire Mart shops to its travel center network

Over the next year, the company plans to add more than 30 STMP shops to its travel centers for a total of over 85 locations across the country.

McCarthy Tire Service promotes new VP of human resources

Ann Sadusky joined the McCarthy team in October 2018 and has directed its human resource department since that time.

McCarthy-Ann-Sadusky--1400
Bridgestone to supply 15 Daytona 200 riders with BattlAx tires

Among the 15 riders, three riders from YART Yamaha, the winners of the 2023 FIM Endurance World Championship, will join Bridgestone’s team.

Bridgestone-Daytona 200

Other Posts

Goodyear adds the RSA ULT, RTD ULT to its RangeMax tire line

Goodyear said the all-position tires help deliver range efficiency through low rolling resistance and long miles to removal.

range-max-RTD-angled
General Tire reveals spring promotion for G-Max, AltiMax tires

Starting March 1-April 30, with the purchase of four qualifying passenger General Tires, customers will receive up to $70.

GeneralTire-GMax-AS07-2.0-1400
SRNA promotes new director of OE for four-wheel and two-wheel businesses

He’s been with SRNA since Feb. 2013, focusing his time on motorcycle OE throughout the entirety of his tenure.

SRNA-Rick-Zimmerman
GRI appoints Barry Guildford as global commercial director

As the GCD, Guilford will lead the global sales and marketing organization of GRI.

GRI-Barry-Guildford