Connect with us

Business Operations

Five-Star Mediocrity: If You’re Not Creating Positively Memorable Experiences, You’re Not Creating True Customers

Specializing in training for independent tire/auto service businesses, I normally steer clear of new vehicle dealerships for tires or service work for my personal vehicles.


Click Here to Read More

Specializing in training for independent tire/auto service businesses, I normally steer clear of new vehicle dealerships for tires or service work for my personal vehicles. The exception to this rule occurred recently week when I brought in my 2016 Chrysler 300, a company car I lease through my business, into my local Jeep-Chrysler dealership in response to a safety recall notice. The issue was to replace the front driveshaft bolts, a situation that could lead to the bolts loosening and allowing the front driveshaft to disconnect. Yikes!

To best understand my experience, let’s borrow a principle for Stephen Covey’s 7 Habits of Highly Effective People and begin with the end in mind. At the end, when I was picking up my car and paying my bill, the associate said, “You’re going to receive a survey from Chrysler regarding your experience. Anything graded less than a 10 is considered a failure. Bill (pointing to his service manager) really wants a 10.” I told the associate (who never bothered to introduce himself), “Of course, everyone wants a 10. Out of curiosity, what do you think was perfect about my experience?”


Looking completely bewildered by my question he responded, “Was there a problem?”

“No, no problem, but since Bill really wants a 10, I’m just wondering if you think my experience was as good as it gets or as good as it could have been?”

“I’m sure we could do better.”

“Exactly,” I replied as we parted ways.

So what did they do? Well, if their objective was simply to get the job done, then mission accomplished. However, if their objective was to provide an extraordinary experience worthy of that desired 10 rating, then they came up short.


Not even close really.

Not having been to this dealership for service before, I expected that they would roll out the red carpet and with balloons, confetti and a ten-foot banner that read “Welcome Steve Ferrante! We’re so happy to have you as a new customer today!”

Actually, I wasn’t expecting that at all. But a “Hi, my name is Bob. Welcome to our dealership” would have been nice. Instead, I got no welcome at all. Just an unceremonious “What can I help ya with?” similar to the reception from your average supermarket deli-counter worker. Seeing as the job was going to require several hours, I inquired if they would be offering a loaner vehicle. “Nope, we don’t do loaners,” I was told. Courtesy shuttle? Again, nope, followed by, “We rent vehicles if you need one”.


With no transportation, and not wanting to spend the better part of the day at the dealership, I went ahead and paid the $35 for one of their rentals, a Ram truck with an interior that reeked so badly of cigarette smoke that I also reeked after the 10 or so minute drive back to my office. A couple of weeks later, I did indeed receive that survey from the dealership. As suspected, the language on the survey made it clear of their intent; to service my vehicle – nothing more, nothing less.

To satisfy or not satisfy is not the question.

On the surface it may seem that simply satisfying the customer’s vehicle needs is the goal. I needed my vehicle repaired; they repaired it. What’s wrong with that?


If their plan was “one and done,” then they did so splendidly because I’m certain I won’t be returning in the future.

Of course, not all new vehicle dealerships are like this. Lexus and Mercedes typically provide outstanding customer experiences and I feature their exemplary service models in my Pinnacle Performance Training.

Are Your Customers Really
Your Customers?

As the Pinnacle team and I have evaluated over 60,000 incoming sales calls (and growing daily) between employees and actual potential customers (not mystery shoppers), I’m well aware of the fact that most owners don’t even take into consideration that a very large percentage of customers aren’t really yours. They’re shoppers. They call around for, and often buy because of, price. Although they may have been a previous customer, now that they’re back in the market for tires or vehicle service, you are now just one of several shops they call, once again, to make their decision based on price. They typically end phone interactions with “Okay, thanks for the information; I’ll let you know.”


These aren’t real customers. They’re transient customers – here today, gone tomorrow. A true customer is one that, when they need tires or vehicle service, they call you. Period. And when a family member or friend needs tires or vehicle service, they recommend and refer you. Anything less than that then you simply do not have a true customer. Now, I’d be willing to bet you do, indeed, have customers like this. You just need more of them. If you’re like all the shop owners I’ve met, then you agree but you’re probably focusing your marketing efforts on getting more traffic in your stores, upping car count and all that jazz.


As you may have heard, it costs 5 to 6 times more to generate a new customer compared to keeping the one you already have. And, if you do that successfully, the value of that loyal customer is typically 10-20 times whatever they spend today. And that’s before they go ahead and refer their family members and friends!

The solution to this is true customer engagement. That does not come from merely satisfying the needs of customers or providing the lowest price. It comes from providing a positively memorable experience.

In a nutshell, poor customer experiences are a bad memory. Average customer experiences are forgettable. The best customer experiences are positively memorable. The cute quote is true; the difference between ordinary and extraordinary is that little “extra.” If all you do is satisfy customers needs then you will lose them as soon as they find a business that does that – plus that little extra. If you sell tires for the lowest price, but with lousy service, not only will the customer not come back, but you have likely lost more than just their business as they share their story of dissatisfaction with their friends and family. If you provide a fair price with average service the customer will be merely satisfied. In this case, you will have made a sale today but not a true customer.


On the other hand, if a customer needs tires and you provide them for a fair price with superior service the customer will be beyond satisfied. Unlike the merely satisfied customer who forgets their average experience and shops around next time, the beyond satisfied customer remembers how they felt and this emotional connection creates a bond with the business and loyalty to the brand.

Be Remarkable or Be Irrelevant

Unless you have a one-of-a-kind product and/or no competition in your market, then being remarkable matters. As consumers, we are flooded with advertising and marketing messages. Precious few of those messages make it through the noise and stand out in our minds. They’re unremarkable.


As I wrote about in my “How To Fail” article (check out page 38 in the October 2016 issue), as potential customers shop around with very little to distinguish one tire business from the next, they naturally default to the cheapest price for the product or service they’re seeking.

While every tire business is capable of being remarkable, only a small minority ever actually achieve it. The majority play it safe, stick to the norm, and deliver ordinary unremarkable customer experiences.

Always remember – you can’t be extraordinary by doing ordinary things!

So ask yourself: Are we truly remarkable? Do we stand out in a positive way and make people take notice? Or do we simply blend in and fade away as just another tire business in our market? At the end of the day, a business’ success is largely determined by its ability to stand out from its competitors and attract more customers.


Being “unremarkable” just won’t cut it.

Steve Ferrante is the CEO of Sale Away LLC. As producer and host of the highly acclaimed “Pinnacle Performance Training” program, Steve is recognized as the leading provider of sales, customer service and corporate culture training and coaching for independent tire/auto service businesses across North America. Steve can be reached at 866-721-6086 ext. 701 or [email protected]

Click to comment


Coats Tread Depth Data Coats Tread Depth Data

Business Operations

Using Data to Enrich the Customer Experience

Business Operations

Creating a Positive Work Environment

Tire Review Magazine