Big O Tire, Parent Firms Sued by Franchisees - Tire Review Magazine

Big O Tire, Parent Firms Sued by Franchisees

Some 20 current and former Big O Tire franchisees in California have sued Big O Tires and its parent companies.

The suit, filed on Dec. 2, 2009, in Los Angeles Superior Court, alleges various “breaches of franchise agreements, restraint of trade violations, interference with contractual rights, fraud in the inducement, negligent misrepresentation, violations of the Cartwright Act, violations of unfair competition law, and other misconduct.”

“The lawsuit sets forth 10 specific causes of actions and seeks declaratory relief as well as compensatory and punitive damages and legal costs in amounts to be determined,” the plaintiffs said in their news release.

Also named as defendants in the suit were Big O Tires parent TBC Corp., and its parents Sumitomo Corporation of America and Sumitomo Corp., as well as a series of named and unnamed individuals.

TBC denies the allegations.

The Dec. 2 “mass tort” suit followed two similar but separate suits filed in August and October 2009 by two other Big O franchise holders. Lawyers for the three parties are seeking to consolidate them into a single suit.

The 18 individuals/companies listed as plaintiffs in the Dec. 2 action have tagged themselves as the Tire Dealer Alliance of California, led by plaintiff Jan Talbott, who is serving as acting chair of the group. The TDA claims it has attempted to mediate its complaints with Big O, “however in recent communications attorneys representing TBC have rejected those proposals,” the group claimed.

In response to the suit, Brian Maciak, vice president and general counsel for the TBC Retail Group, based in Juno Beach, Fla., issued this statement:

“Although Big O typically does not comment on pending litigation, it is necessary to respond to the Mar. 26, press release issued by the Tire Dealer Alliance of California to ensure that the public record is described accurately.
 
“Three lawsuits have recently been filed in California by a splintered minority of franchisees operating as Tire Dealer Alliance of California, a group not recognized by Big O. Although the majority of Big O franchisees operate successfully and share a dynamic partnership with Big O, the small group of franchisees behind these lawsuits has failed to operate their stores well in the current economy and have resorted to baseless lawsuits. Big O denies all claims asserted against it in these suits.
 
“The Los Angeles Superior Court recently agreed with Big O, dismissing seven of the 12 claims brought by (one) former franchisee. The court also dismissed Big O’s affiliates TBC Corp. and Sumitomo Corporation of America from this suit because (the franchisee) had no viable claims against either entity. Big O has filed similar motions in the other two lawsuits and is optimistic it will receive similar rulings.  
 
“In addition, Big O recently fared well in Federal Court in Colorado in a suit to enjoin a plaintiff in one of the California lawsuits. (The franchisee) refused to “de-identify” [e.g., stop using Big O Tires’ trademarks] after one of his franchise agreements expired. The court issued a temporary restraining order against (the franchisee) and ordered him to turn over his customer list and telephone numbers to Big O as required by his franchise agreement.
 
“Big O sincerely regrets being involved in litigation with any of its current and former franchisees. Nonetheless, Big O intends to vigorously defend each of these lawsuits, and will assert all affirmative claims/counterclaims where appropriate.”

[Editor’s Note: Tire Review has withheld the names of specific plaintiffs at this time, and has substituted descriptions noted in parentheses.]

You May Also Like

Yokohama Rubber reveals 2024 motorsports activity plan

Yokohama said participation in motorsports activities is crucial to its efforts to strengthen the Advan and GeoLandar brands.

Yokohama-Nitrocross

Yokohama Rubber revealed its motorsports activity plan for 2024. The company said participation in motorsports activities is crucial to its efforts to strengthen the Advan and GeoLandar brands and is again participating in a wide variety of motorsports events around the globe, from top-category to grassroots events.

Yokohama Rubber will again supply its Advan tires to many teams participating in motorsports events, such as Japan’s Super GT, the Nürburgring 24-Hour Race and the Pikes Peak International Hill Climb. Yokohama Rubber’s GeoLandar tires will be supplied to teams participating in off-road races in North America and Asia, including the Baja 1000, King of the Hammers, the Mint 400 and the Asia Cross Country Rally.

TIA’s Advanced Farm Tire Service training to take place in June

The training class for technicians in the agricultural and farm tire industries is set to take place June 11-14.

TIA_training-
Maxxis-sponsored athletes make podium, overall top 10 at Mint 400

Maxxis athletes Michael McFayden, Ethan Ebert and Trey Gibbs had podium finishes at the Mint 400 on Maxxis RAZR XT tires.

2024-mint400-maxxis
Sun Auto Tire reveals winner of Ford Bronco Sport giveaway

Lowell Anderson entered the giveaway at his local Sun Auto Tire & Service store while receiving a routine oil change.

Sun-Auto-Bronco-giveaway
Nokian Tyres holds bracket challenge on worst roads in North America

In 2023, the tiremaker’s audience voted Quebec as the province or state with the worst road conditions on the continent.

Pothole-Protection-from-Nokian-Tyres

Other Posts

Gallery: 2024 Big O Tires conference and convention

Highlights from this year’s Big O Tires conference and convention, featuring a general session, trade show and breakout sessions.

Gary-Skidmore
Bridgestone’s Firestone Liberia rubber farm receives ISCC Plus recognition

According to Bridgestone, its Liberia facility earned the ISCC Plus certification for its efforts in reducing environmental impacts.

Firestone_Liberia
Ascenso Tires adds new OEM sales manager

Douglas Duesing has more than ten years of experience working in agriculture, construction and mining OEMs.

Ascenso-Douglas-Duesing-1400
Nexen Tire Motorsports drivers earn top placements at King of the Hammers

Nexen Tire Motorsports partnered with drivers across a variety of racing series both on- and off-road, including King of the Hammers.

Nexen-KOH